The Yankees farm system had a terrific year in 2015. Luis Severino forced his way to the Majors and met even the most optimistic fans' expectations. Greg Bird similarly arrived in the Bronx and quite possibly Wally Pipp'ed the team's All Star 1B stalwart Mark Teixeira, (ok probably not but on a team more progressive than the Yankees it might be possible). Slade Heathcott, Mason Williams, Rob Refsnyder and other prospects all gave the team strong contributions. The future is bright. Ironically this will result in the farm system being ranked lower next year than it did at the beginning of 2015 because Severino and Bird graduated due to their service time in August and September. This just goes to show: farm system rankings aren't the end-all-be-all.
First, before the rankings I have a disclosure: I am not a scout. I do not communicate directly with scouts. I do not regularly watch the prospects in person, on television, or on the Internet. My opinions are informed by websites and publications such as Baseball America, Fangraphs, and ESPN.com and interactions with fans and writers on social media. I am simply a fan who is expressing his opinion; take it for what it's worth.
Ok, here are the Yankees' top 30 prospects:
Rank | Name | POS |
1 | Aaron Judge | RF |
2 | Jorge Mateo | SS |
3 | Gary Sanchez | C |
4 | James Kaprielian | SP |
5 | Wilkerman Garcia | SS/3B |
6 | Domingo Acevedo | SP |
7 | Jacob Lindgren | RP |
8 | Rob Refsnyder | 2B/LF |
9 | Eric Jagielo | 3B/1B |
10 | Rookie Davis | SP |
11 | Tyler Wade | SS |
12 | Ian Clarkin | SP |
13 | Hoy-Jun Park | SS |
14 | Miguel Andujar | 3B |
15 | Abiatal Avelino | SS/2B |
16 | Luis Torrens | C |
17 | Jake Cave | CF |
18 | Mason Williams | CF |
19 | Brady Lail | SP |
20 | Angel Aguilar | SS/3B |
21 | Slade Heathcott | CF |
22 | Drew Finley | SP |
23 | Domingo German | SP |
24 | Dustin Fowler | CF/RF |
25 | Austin DeCarr | SP |
26 | Juan de Leon | CF/RF |
27 | Dermis Garcia | 3B |
28 | Leonardo Molina | CF |
29 | Thairo Estrada | SS |
30 | Nelson Gomez | 3B |
Let's compare the last list to this one. First, players who were in the previous rankings but not this one, (including previous ranking):
1. Luis Severino (graduated)
4. Greg Bird (graduated)
22. Kyle Holder (out of top 30)
And now, the players who were not in the previous ranking but are now in this one, (including current ranking):
5. Wilkerman Garcia
14. Hoy Jun-Park
30. Nelson Gomez
For those who like deep dives, here's a top 30 hitters list:
Rank | Player | Position | Born |
1 | Aaron Judge | RF | 1992 |
2 | Jorge Mateo | SS | 1995 |
3 | Gary Sanchez | C | 1992 |
4 | Wilkerman Garcia | SS/3B | 1998 |
5 | Rob Refsnyder | 2B/LF | 1991 |
6 | Eric Jagielo | 3B/1B | 1992 |
7 | Tyler Wade | SS | 1994 |
8 | Hoy-Jun Park | SS | 1996 |
9 | Miguel Andujar | 3B | 1995 |
10 | Abiatal Avelino | SS/2B | 1995 |
11 | Luis Torrens | C | 1996 |
12 | Jake Cave | CF | 1992 |
13 | Mason Williams | CF | 1991 |
14 | Angel Aguilar | SS/3B | 1995 |
15 | Slade Heathcott | CF | 1990 |
16 | Dustin Fowler | CF/RF | 1994 |
17 | Juan de Leon | CF/RF | 1998 |
18 | Dermis Garcia | 3B | 1998 |
19 | Leonardo Molina | CF | 1997 |
20 | Thairo Estrada | SS | 1996 |
21 | Nelson Gomez | 3B | 1997 |
22 | Jhalan Jackson | OF | 1993 |
23 | Kyle Holder | SS | 1994 |
24 | Tyler Austin | RF/1B | 1991 |
25 | Ben Gamel | RF | 1992 |
26 | Miguel Flames | C/3B | 1997 |
27 | Diego Castillo | SS/2B | 1997 |
28 | Trey Amburgey | OF | 1994 |
29 | Alexander Palma | RF | 1995 |
30 | Tony Renda | 2B | 1991 |
And now, the pitchers:
Rank | Player | Position | Born |
1 | James Kaprielian | SP | 1994 |
2 | Domingo Acevedo | SP | 1994 |
3 | Jacob Lindgren | RP | 1993 |
4 | Rookie Davis | SP | 1993 |
5 | Ian Clarkin | SP | 1995 |
6 | Brady Lail | SP | 1993 |
7 | Drew Finley | SP | 1996 |
8 | Domingo German | SP | 1992 |
9 | Austin DeCarr | SP | 1995 |
10 | Jordan Montgomery | SP | 1992 |
11 | Cale Coshow | SP/RP | 1992 |
12 | Jonathan Holder | SP | 1993 |
13 | Jeff Degano | SP | 1992 |
14 | Simon de la Rosa | SP | 1993 |
15 | Ty Hensley | SP | 1993 |
16 | Vicente Campos | SP/RP | 1992 |
17 | Nick Rumbelow | RP | 1991 |
18 | Nick Goody | RP | 1991 |
19 | James Pazos | RP | 1991 |
20 | Josh Rogers | SP | 1994 |
21 | Tyler Webb | RP | 1990 |
22 | Gilmael Troya | SP/RP | 1997 |
23 | Alexander Vargas | SP | 1997 |
24 | Johnny Barbato | RP | 1992 |
25 | Luis Cedeno | SP/RP | 1994 |
26 | Jordan Foley | SP/RP | 1993 |
27 | Chance Adams | RP | 1994 |
28 | Miguel Sulbaran | SP/RP | 1994 |
29 | Chaz Hebert | SP | 1992 |
30 | Caleb Smith | SP/RP | 1991 |
Well, let me know what you think. My Twitter handle is @thebronxempire and my email is bembry24@gmail.com. I'll update the list this fall after the season. Ok, have a good day!
Not that I disagree with any of this, because WOW what a great post, but I do wonder what made you rank certain players in certain places.
ReplyDeleteFor instance, Wilkerman Garcia over Domingo Acevedo?
Having Tony Renda as the 30th best hitter?
FYI I love the Park ranking. Would like to see Rookie Davis higher but the only player you can make a true case over in Jagielo and what's one spot.. right?
Great work Ben. GREAT work.
That was a lot of work Ben, very good work at that...thank you!
ReplyDeleteI think it is very subjective but, then again not much would change...well maybe one or two, but one place up or down means very little. Next year is the year I am looking forward to, let's see how many improve their standings and by how much!
Jorge Mateo should be marked as SS/2nd baseman...he has been working out in both places.
Reed I don't see Mitchell on there unless I am overlooking it.
DeleteMitchell is missing, you're right. Mitchell is better than a lot of the guys on the Top 30 pitchers... it was an obvious oversight.
DeleteAs I am not tied to one player, I didn't notice he wasn't there, I was looking at those that were there to be critiqued. Now that you guys have mentioned it...I object to the whole list and think it is a waste of time and money!
DeleteJust kidding Ben!