Thoughts Concerning Harper/Machado After Signing Of DJ LeMahieu

For the second time this off season the Yankees have signed someone that basically kills an idea I posted about moments before.

I just wrote about the Yankees signing Marwin Gonzalez, and not two minutes after I did so news came out that they agreed to a two-year contract with infielder DJ LeMahieu.

While there's a chance Gonzalez could be signed to start regularly in left field over Brett Gardner, I don't believe they will do that. Nor should they. I wasn't attracted to Marwin because he was so much better than Gardner offensively (he's not), but because of Marwin's ability to play at so many positions both in the infield and outfield. That's not necessary any longer.

But one thing to keep in mind, which has already been talked about all over Twitter, is the signing of LeMahieu does not kill the chances the Yankees sign Manny Machado.

It would be great having a multi-time Gold Glove winner regularly in the infield, but the fact is DJ is not so good that he wouldn't be used more as a utility player. DJ's OPS+ over the past two seasons is only 91.

So the idea that this signing kills the chances of bringing in Manny Machado is silly.

The same goes for Bryce Harper, although that's more obvious since Harper does not play the infield like Machado does.

However, one thing you can take from this latest signing is that the Yankees will not be signing both Manny Machado and Bryce Harper. Although that doesn't upset me because I didn't think that was going to happen anyway, no matter how much I thought they should do that.

To prove those things to you here are the two rosters we'd likely see if either Machado or Harper were signed...

with Machado
1. Hicks - CF
2. Judge - RF
3. Machado - SS
4. Stanton - DH
5. Sanchez - C
6. Andujar - 3B
7. Torres - 2B
8. Voit - 1B
9. Gardner - LF

Bench: Romine, Bird, Tulowitski, LeMahieu

with Harper
1. Hicks - CF
2. Judge - RF
3. Harper - LF
4. Stanton - DH
5. Sanchez - C
6. Andujar - 3B
7. Torres - 2B
8. Tulowitski - SS
9. Voit - 1B

Bench: Romine, Bird, Gardner, LeMahieu

Now, I will admit that the roster with Machado is lacking something... an outfielder on the bench. So if there's any reason why Manny is less likely after the news of signing LeMahieu then that is it.

Of course, the Yankees could always choose to trade one of Bird or Voit, allowing them to open up a roster spot for an outfielder on the bench. Which is not that far out of the realm of possibility.

So let's not lose hope yet. And let's certainly not lose our heads, either.