Showing posts with label Eat This Not That. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Eat This Not That. Show all posts

Saturday, August 6, 2016

Eat This, Not That: Yankees Youth Movement Edition


The youth movement has finally, and I mean FINALLY, begun in New York after Brian Cashman shook up the organization and traded away a ton of veteran talent before the August 1st trading deadline. The farm system is now restocked and many believe that the Yankees have the top farm system in all of Major League Baseball. If you don’t agree with that you have to agree that they at least have a Top 3 farm system in the league but all that gets you in the grand scheme of things is a whole lot of promise and not enough MLB talent paying dividends if you don’t use them like the Yankees have been known to historically do. The team did call up Gary Sanchez before Wednesday night’s game with the New York Mets at least showing a willingness to build from within and reward some of their own but you can’t stop there. Keep the youth movement, and the good times, rolling.

If the Yankees want to keep giving at bats to the youth (Eat This) instead of letting the contracts of aging and under-producing veterans (Not That) then here are a few options for Brian Cashman and company to consider for the remainder of the 2016 season.

Eat This: Tyler Austin
Not That: Mark Teixeira

We discussed this earlier today but I mean it. You guys came out and said you could eat the contracts of both Alex Rodriguez and Mark Teixeira if you sold at the trading deadline, and you did just as an FYI, so why is Teixeira and his sub-.200 batting average still on the team? Especially considering Austin’s performance in Triple-A both with the bat and the glove at first base. Austin has more home runs in Triple-A than Teixeira may hit ever again throughout his career. A slight exaggeration but an exaggeration that needed to be done for emphasis because Austin 110% deserves to be here and Teixeira, despite what his contract says, does not.

Eat This: Aaron Judge
Not That: Alex Rodriguez

The Yankees have #TooManyDamnOFs right now and no clear way to fix it. Not unless you stick to your word and eat the remaining year and a half of Alex Rodriguez’s contract and bring up some right-handed pop to rotate in and out of the DH position. Gary Sanchez is already here to provide some depth but Aaron Judge needs to be as well. Let him get the at bats that Aaron Hicks was getting, and again not deserving of, and let him slide into the DH role every now and then and really kick start this whole rebuild thing instead of just talking about it all day.

Eat This: Ben Gamel
Not That: Aaron Hicks

Speaking of Aaron Hicks there is no reason to be here if Judge is going to get the bulk of his playing time. His defense is pretty good but his bat has been horrendous and his inability to perform fundamentals like laying down a bunt should be the final straw and the straw that breaks the camel’s back on this team.

Eat This: Pick Your Poison
Not That: Anthony Swarzak and Richard Bleier


Neither Swarzak nor Bleier have a future with the club and neither have been especially effective either so why have them both in the bullpen? Bring up a kid and let him get his feet wet. There are plenty to choose from, Tyler Webb for example and Chasen Shreve as another and recently acquired Ben Heller as a third, so pick one and call them up. Use the wash that is the 2016 season wisely and build from within.  

Weekly Prospects Check In: Tyler Austin


If you read the blog yesterday you know that I now condone eating this, and not that, and when I say “this” I mean Yankees prospects. The first Yankees prospect that should come up and continue the youth movement and the rebuild is the showcase of today’s weekly check in post, Tyler Austin.

Austin has done more than enough to earn a shot at the Major Leagues after starting the season out in Double-A. Who could blame the Yankees for starting Austin down in Trenton after numerous injuries and a couple down seasons full on struggle but Austin was called up to Triple-A to play first base and he has absolutely made the best of the situation crushing the baseball and playing a good first base all while putting his name back on the radar and the prospects map.


Wouldn’t it make sense to not only reward your prospects for earning their chance at the Majors with a call up but to also try a young guy in the midst of a rebuild instead of an aging veteran who has shown to have little to nothing left in the tank offensively? Maybe it’s just me. 

YearAgeLevGPARH2BHRRBISBBBSOBAOBPSLGOPS
201624AAA-AA1024285910530177666298.290.393.519.912
201624AA5021022461042913046.260.367.395.762
201624AAA52218375920134753252.319.417.6381.055

Wednesday, July 22, 2015

Eat This, Not That: 2015 Yankees Edition


We’ve all seen the books and read the articles and tried the miracle diets and all come back with the same conclusion, if you’re reading it in a book then something isn’t working out. While this goes for the food we eat or the shows we watch on television it can also go for the players that Brian Cashman and company are putting on the field every single night while the far more superior players get over-groomed in the minor leagues. Eat this Cashman, not that!

Eat This:

Robert Refsnyder

YearLevGPARH2BHRRBISBBBSOBAOBPSLGOPS
2015AAA81364459017737104444.290.387.413.800
Not That:

Stephen Drew

Year Tm G PA R H 2B HR RBI SB BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+
2015 NYY 80 280 26 45 11 12 25 0 26 46 .181 .255 .369 .625 72
You don’t wait until you fall out of first place to make the move, especially in a highly contested American League East Division. With that kind of mindset the Yankees won’t add anything at the trading deadline.

Eat This:

Jose Pirela

Year Lg G PA R H 2B HR RBI SB BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+
2015 AAA,AA,A+ 26 116 22 33 10 2 11 2 8 15 .308 .362 .458 .820
2015 AL 29 70 6 14 3 1 4 1 2 14 .212 .232 .303 .535 48
Not That:

Brendan Ryan

Year Tm G PA R H 2B HR RBI SB BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+
2015 NYY 7 15 1 4 0 0 2 0 1 1 .308 .400 .462 .862 140
Jose Pirela can play more positions then Brendan Ryan while Ryan has a better shot of being hit by the ball while he’s being struck by lightning then outhitting Pirela over the course of a season.

Eat This:

Aaron Judge


YearLevGPARH2BHRRBISBBBSOBAOBPSLGOPS
2015AA-AAA84375459319145523688.282.352.485.837
2015AA63280367116124412470.284.350.516.866
2015AAA2195922321111218.275.358.388.745
Not That:

Carlos Beltran

Year Tm G PA R H 2B HR RBI SB BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+
2015 NYY 67 265 21 64 18 7 31 0 17 49 .262 .313 .430 .744 105
This seems unfair because Beltran has hit much better since coming off the disabled list and was hitting well before he went on the disabled list but the prospect humper inside of me forced me to put this down. The other Daniel Burch made me do it, blame him…. But still make the move.

Eat This:

Luis Severino


YearLevWLERAGGSIPHRERHRBBSOHBPWHIPH9HR9BB9SO9
2015AAA-AA722.45171788.16529242258441.0196.60.22.58.6
2015AA223.328838.03217142104821.1057.60.52.411.4
2015AAA501.799950.13312100153620.9545.90.02.76.4
Not That:

Chris Capuano


Year W L ERA G GS GF IP H R ER HR BB SO ERA+ FIP WHIP H9 HR9 BB9 SO9
2015 0 4 4.76 13 3 5 28.1 33 17 15 3 10 28 83 3.84 1.518 10.5 1.0 3.2 8.9
Limit Severino’s innings while getting something useful out of a guy clearly under matched at Triple-A despite being six years younger than the average AAA player instead of wasting bullets and quality starts for your farm team. It worked for David Phelps, it worked for Adam Warren and it could work for Severino. And don’t even mention Joba Chamberlain because this is nothing like that and Joba started going downhill after the shoulder inflammation… so there! Plus it’s Chris Capuano, enough said.