Ramirez, who's spent the last two and a half years with the Dodgers, is set to become a free agent this winter. At the relatively young age of 30, he is considered by some to be a possible successor to Derek Jeter, who retired last month after two decades with the team.
"By the numbers, Ramirez, even by the diminished standards of his 2014 season, would have led the Yankees in on-base percentage, slugging percentage and OPS, been one tick behind Ichiro Suzuki for highest batting average and run second to Brian McCann in RBIs," Matthews' pros read.
Mattews opined that those facts probably say more about the Yankees' offense than Ramirez's talents, but that the latter would still help them out.
As for the cons, Matthews mentioned the veteran's injury history, which goes back to his days as a Marlin.
"Injuries have shortened three of Ramirez's past four seasons, causing his production to plummet," he wrote. "Alas, his age is not plummeting, and if the Yankees balked at giving a 30-year-old Cano a 10-year deal, why would they lock themselves up with Ramirez for at least five years?"
Matthews eventually concluded his piece by saying the Yankees should pass on Ramirez, claiming that acquiring him wouldn't work well in the long run. According to Matthews, younger, cheaper options are currently out there, and that the Yanks would be smart to wait for one.