Sadly, the Season Ends or is it the Season Ends Sadly...

 

Carlos Rodon, Giancarlo Stanton, & Aaron Judge (Photo Credit: Jason Szenes/NY Post)

The Yankees botch their way out of championship dreams…

The World Series did not begin or finish as we would have liked, but I appreciate the 2024 New York Yankees making it to MLB’s Championship Series. Undoubtedly, much second-guessing and finger-pointing can be done, but it serves no purpose. The Yankees were beaten by the better team. A more deserving team? Maybe not, but ‘what will be, will be’. I congratulate the Los Angeles Dodgers, a franchise that has historically played second fiddle to the great Yankees teams over the last century.

The World Series loss does not need to define the current group of Yankees. We do not know who will take the field in 2025 outside of a select few, but I remember feeling as low as I have ever felt as a Yankees fan after the 1995 playoff loss to the Seattle Mariners in Don Mattingly’s final voyage wearing the famed Pinstripes. I think the next few years after that horrific loss ended well if memory serves correctly. The Yankees have much to do this off-season, but how they rebound will determine how history views them. There is time for Aaron Judge to prove that he can be a money player when the chips are on the line. I know his 2024 post-season was forgettable, and I have seen those who say it will define how they perceive him going forward, but why? I am more interested in watching Judge re-write his story next season.

There is no question the Yankees need Juan Soto. I am concerned. While I would like to think the Yankees made a strong, positive impression on the young slugger, I am sure he enjoyed the rock star reception he received at home and on the road as part of baseball’s most storied franchise. However, his agent is Scott Boras, and millions of dollars will be a more significant determinant of his next team than millions of Yankees fans.  Watching Soto go across town for the Mets or join the current World Series Champions will be tough. However, Soto’s final decision does not alter the fact that I love the New York Yankees.  I hope Hal Steinbrenner is actively involved in the negotiations and does everything he needs to ensure that Juan Soto and Aaron Judge are the keystone tandem for the immediate future. Soto’s presence helps Judge, and it helps everybody else in the lineup.  Soto’s return will help ensure the Yankees can return to the World Series with the right offseason moves. While I do not feel that Aaron Judge in center field and Juan Soto in right are the best alignments, the Yankees have an offseason to figure out the correct usage of the players if Soto returns. The Yankees are better with Judge in the right field, but Judge and Soto are more powerful together in the same lineup.

Juan Soto & Aaron Judge (Photo Credit: Alex Slitz/Getty Images)

As much as I loved Soto this season, it was hard to fully embrace him, knowing he was possibly a one-year rental. I so hope that does not prove to be factual. I will fully embrace Soto next season if he returns to the Bronx on a long-term deal.  I wanted the Yankees to sign Gerrit Cole. They did. I wanted the Yankees to sign Aaron Judge. They did. I want the Yankees to sign Juan Soto. They…to be determined.

I was sad to see the Yankees decline the mutual option on first baseman Anthony Rizzo, but I hardly fault the club's decision. I wish we had experienced a young Rizzo, and I am grateful that we experienced the time we did, but the Yankees can do better at first base. I cannot say that I would be enthused about signing Mets free agent first baseman Pete Alonso, but he would be an upgrade. Even if I like Rizzo better than Alonso, Alonso is clearly the better player at this point in their respective careers. Although the Yankees should (and most likely will) move on from outfielder Alex Verdugo, Verdugo proved I could get behind a player I formerly despised. Marcus Stroman is in that category, too. Stroman’s finish to the season was not good, but I thought he did well enough as a middle-of-the-rotation starter. If you placed higher expectations, of course, you would be disappointed. However, I genuinely believe that both Verdugo and Stroman valued wearing Pinstripes, and regardless of what their respective futures hold, I wish them the best as they move forward. I think the Yankees will move on from both players. Yet, if they return, I will support either one, or I hope they can make the adjustments to make 2025 better than 2024.

The Yankees’ decision to pick up the club option on reliever Luke Weaver might be the easiest decision the Cashman Administration has ever made.  Weaver proved that he could carry the closing torch in 2025 and that it was worth more than the Yankees were paying him. I hope they take care of him and reward him for excelling in the bullpen when his pay was structured for a starter.  As much as I wanted the Yankees to replace Clay Holmes as closer, I appreciate Holmes was better in a setup role. It was probably not enough to convince the Yankees to bring him back, but he is another player who is most likely out the door through free agency, yet I would support his return.  The Yankees need to improve their bullpen in the offseason, and there is comfort in knowing that Weaver has the back door covered. He will need guys who can bridge the gap from the starters to keep games in position to win in the final inning (or two). If not, I hope the Yankees can find someone who can consistently be the “good” Holmes before Weaver takes the mound. 

Anthony Volpe must go on a soul-searching expedition this offseason to find his better self and discover what it takes to elevate his game to the next level. Go spend a few weeks in Florida with Derek Jeter. Fortunately, youth and talent are on his side, so I am cautiously optimistic he will arrive in Tampa next Spring as a man on a mission. I am not ready to say the Yankees need to find a new shortstop, but next season will be our final answer. 

Anthony Volpe (Photo Credit: Vincent Marchietta/Imagn Images)

The season is over, and I want Gleyber Torres back. I know he was frustrating for the average Yankees fan to watch this season, particularly the first half. Yet, he showed enough later in the year that it is not time to part ways.  He excelled in the problematic leadoff position and would be hard to replace. I would be sad to see Gleyber playing for a division rival or the Kansas City Royals next year. Maybe Caleb Durbin is destined to be an All-Star second baseman. Volpe proved that it generally takes time with any young, talented player. I would rather go with the certainty Gleyber brings in 2025 than handing Durbin his training wheels. Some will be happy to see Gleyber leave but do not count me among that group.  The Yankees need Gleyber to reclaim the AL Championship in 2025. They can make the World Series without him, yes, but the path is more accessible with him.

Gleyber Torres (Photo Credit: Charles Wenzelberg/NY Post)

I have long respected DJ LeMahieu. For the years I lived in Denver, he might have been my favorite Rockie on the local team. Despite the injuries, I have appreciated his time as a Yankee, but it is time to move on because of the injuries and his age. I am tired of the Yankees playing players out of position. LeMahieu is a second baseman who can play third or first. It does not mean I want him as the team’s starting third or first baseman.  Maybe the Yankees will move out of position third baseman Jazz Chisholm, Jr to second base, his natural position if Gleyber leaves, but in his case, there is a reason the Miami Marlins decided to move him to the outfield.  Hard to explain or understand any decision by the Marlins, but as the saying goes, where there is smoke, there is fire. For LeMahieu, it is time to bite the bullet and eat his contract ala Josh Donaldson and Jacoby Ellsbury.  I am not interested in seeing if he can stay healthy next season, as he will be a year older and on the fast track in the age regression lane.  Bring me legitimate third and first basemen!

The Yankees must either commit to helping Jasson Dominguez become a valued left fielder for the team or move on. Dominguez did not show enough to prove he is a 2025 answer, but I will support the Yankees if they believe he will. If they believe he cannot overcome his flaws, move on and find a left fielder who gives us the confidence of Brett Gardner in the role. I am tired of the continued black hole in the position since Gardy left.

As for the coaching staff, Aaron Boone solidified his return with the World Series appearance, and Brad Ausmus was an effective bench coach. I like Luis Rojas, and I thought he was an improvement over Phil Nevin, but it is time for a new third-base coach. Did James Rowson excel as the team’s hitting coach? I am not so sure. I could go either way on his return. Matt Blake will be back, as he should, but there is work to be done with the starting rotation and bullpen.  Travis Chapman remains the coach I know nothing about.

Gerrit Cole exercised the opt-out in his contract today, but I would be shocked if the Yankees let him go. He is the team’s ace, and nothing is comparable on the free-agent market (despite Blake Snell’s opt-out in San Francisco). Gerrit Cole is a Yankee and will be one when April rolls around. I fully expect the Yankees to add the one year at $36 million to his contract that will void the opt-out.  If Weaver was an easy decision, this is the second easiest. Or maybe the easiest when you consider what Cole brings to the rotation. If Hal lets Cole leave over $36 million, the team is not serious about contending next season. 

It is hard to think about any moves while Juan Soto is free. I want a quick resolution, but I know this will be long and drawn out. I hope it does not prevent the Yankees from making the other necessary moves to eliminate the 2024 flaws that prevented them from enjoying champagne at the season’s end. 

The Yankees generally disappoint us every offseason, and I expect this year to be no different. They always do a little but need more. Cashman, please prove me wrong. You, sir, are on the clock…

As always, Go Yankees!