Monday, September 28, 2015

ICYMI:Starlin Castro, the Next Great Yankees Second Baseman

The New York Yankees let Robinson Cano walk to Seattle along with Jay-Z a few seasons back now and the team has had what the experts like to call a “black hole” at second base ever since. New York has plugged in the likes of Yangervis Solarte, Brian Roberts, Kelly Johnson, Stephen Drew, Brendan Ryan and now Dustin Ackley at the position with varying degrees of success while leaving much to be desired out of the position. The team does not seem sold on the emergence and development of Robert Refsnyder at the position so does this mean the team would be willing to work out an offseason acquisition with the Chicago Cubs for Starlin Castro making his the next great second baseman for the franchise?

Castro was one of the few bright spots for the Chicago Cubs during the rebuilding years and now that the team is flush with talent from their minor league system the franchise has seemingly shunned their former shortstop. Castro was moved from shortstop to second base to make room for Addison Russel and has been the talk of trade rumors for much of his age 25 season in 2015. Castro has had his fair share of ups and downs in his career but has turned it on lately hitting .345 with five home runs in his last months’ worth of games building his trade value to maybe its highest it has ever been.

Castro would fit right into the mold that the New York Yankees are trying to build their team around, middle infielders who can defend, carry their own with the bat and infielders that can play multiple positions. Defense, offense and versatility in that order and Castro owns all three. Castro will be just 26-years old at the beginning of the 2016 season thus fitting in with the Yankees semi-youth movement and is signed through the 2019 season at a reasonable rate with a club option for 2020. Castro never makes more than $11 million in salary in one season, and keep in mind that the Yankees paid $5 million each for Stephen Drew and Chris Capuano this season, and comes attached to a $16 million club option. For a shortstop or second baseman that can hit that’s relatively cheap, ask Robinson Cano and the Seattle Mariners about it.

What would it cost to acquire Castro? While he may come cheap in terms of a contract he won’t come cheap in terms of the prospect package. For a young, cheap and controllable piece though there aren’t many names that I wouldn’t include. Robert Refsnyder? Take him. Gary Sanchez? Sure. The problem is the team is flush full of infield and catching help, they need pitching. They would ask for Aaron Judge and I’d have to decline, same for Severino, but if it was a Bryan Mitchell led package with Ivan Nova, Branden Pinder, Jacob Lindgren, Caleb Cotham, etc. then I would at least have to listen.


  1. STARLIN CASTRO....I know you want everyone, but please, let common sense prevail.
    I was with you on the first two trade chips, and then I lost you (as usual) when you started
    to offer everyone.
    There will be a second baseman next year. Is he here now ? Not sure.
    But, that hole will be plugged.

    Pitching / second baseman....Winter targets for sure.

    1. The first two trade chips are okay (Ref and Sanchez) but not Pineder, Cotham and all the other marginal prospects (aside from Lindgren) that I offered? I'm confused...

    2. I agree with your assessment Daniel we have Judge, Bird, Mateo, Slade, and a few others on the way.

  2. MORE YEARS than I will mention....watching Yankee campaigns...has educated me.

    I can not get excited over this collection of talent. Too many flaws.
    Never in all my years have I seen soooo many men left in scoring position. Never.

    I am convinced that this squad, as composed, will break your heart.
    Yours, not mine.
    I came in with the Larson game. I have clarity.

    1. Aw, Patrick, I came in back in1943 when I heard my first WS WIN and they went on another bunch of WS wins.
      !947 thru 1964 they won 11 of 15 WS then the s-it hit the fan, 1965 -1976 and then 1979 -1995 so I never give up on this team.

      You guys are all spoiled, five WS wins in 20 years...made the playoffs every year except 4 that ain't bad.

      I think living thru the 1960s thru 1980s that is 30 years with only 4 WS that is a BAD way to get CLARITY.

      Hopefully, there won't be a long time before the Yankees win another WS Ring!

    2. The Yankees will be back, if the money is spent wisely, in 2018-2020. No more luxury tax restrictions (or not 50% o every dollar anyway), no more Arod, CC and Tex contracts and hopefully some young talent.


Sorry for the Capatcha... Blame the Russians :)