We’re back, and we are as controversial as ever as we
continue to right wrongs and correct a lot of misinformation that gets passed
around via Yankees fans and Yankees “fans” alike. Last week we analyzed the
reason and history behind the luxury tax threshold in Major League Baseball and
used our findings to determine whether the Yankees would be better off, worse
off, or about the same today if George Steinbrenner were running the team as opposed
to having Hal Steinbrenner run the team, and we are going to look to do
something similar today with first year rookie manager Aaron Boone and his
predecessor, Joe Girardi. Would the 2018 Yankees, a team on pace to win 100
games, be better off, worse off, or about the same with Joe Girardi at the helm
this season? Let’s analyze.
We have to remember that Aaron Boone is a rookie manager
with no managerial or coaching experience anywhere within baseball before
taking the job with the New York Yankees. If that is a problem to some, it is
not a problem with me to be honest, then that blame should be on Brian Cashman
and Hal Steinbrenner as well as the coaching staff that they approved and
assembled around Boone, and the blame should not be on Boone himself. Anyway,
Girardi was not a rookie manager in his first year in the Bronx and was not
foreign to the idea of playing under the watchful eyes of Yankees fans and the
media in New York, he played here and won World Series championships here in
New York, but even with that experience under his belt his first season, 2008,
did not go exactly according to plan.
In 2008 the Yankees missed the postseason for the first time
since the 1993 season with Joe Girardi at the helm, and to add salt in the
wound it was the final season of the old Yankee Stadium as well. Now, one could
argue that Boone has a much better roster than Girardi had at his disposal in
2008, but I cannot say I fully agree with it. Does Boone have a younger team?
Sure. A more versatile team? Probably. A better team though? That’s
questionable, given and assuming health and all that. Girardi had Derek Jeter,
Jorge Posada, Jason Giambi, Robinson Cano, Bobby Abreu, Johnny Damon, Alex
Rodriguez, Hideki Matsui, Brett Gardner, 20-game winner Mike Mussina, Andy
Pettitte, Mariano Rivera, a good version of Joba Chamberlain, David Robertson,
Phil Coke, and a slew of other players that were at-minimum serviceable MLB-caliber
players. Sure, the Yankees had a lot of injuries that season, but if that isn’t
an excuse for Boone than it isn’t an excuse for Girardi either. Also, sure,
Boone does himself no favors with his pitching and in-game decisions, but does
anyone remember Joe Girardi’s binder and the subsequent memes and Twitter
accounts that have popped up since making such a mockery of the same problem
that Girardi had as well?
Want to know a difference? While Boone is on pace to win
right at 100 games this season in his rookie season and make the postseason in
the American League, Joe Girardi led the Yankees to an 89-73 record, a third-place
finish, and to a nice place on their couches during October for the first time
of Derek Jeter’s illustrious career. Of course, Girardi got better as the years
went on, but then again so did his teams, so I find it truly remarkable and
irresponsible to say that this current team would be better under Girardi than
they are under Boone. Boone didn’t injure the players and he damn sure didn’t
make many of them underperform. Now should Boone ever bring AJ Cole into a game
ever again? No. But did Girardi have his favorites and do the same damn thing?
Absolutely, and probably more so than Boone. And let’s be real, Brian Cashman
and Larry Rothschild are calling more of these pitching change calls than we
will ever admit or want to think about.
The team is fine, and Aaron Boone is a fine manager. Joe
Girardi was a fine manager. They both had great things about them and they both
had things that made me want to break any screen that I watched the game on.
That’s baseball, and that’s especially baseball in New York. Deal with it.